2023. no 1. Vladimir Bobrovnikov
Rehabilitation of the Crimean Khanate by Historians
in a five-volumes book about the Crimean Tatars
Institute of Oriental Studies of the Russian Academy of Sciences;
St. Petersburg University;
National Research University – Higher School of Economics
Abstract. Author of the article analyzes the 3rd volume of the History of the Crimean Tatars, dedicated to the Crimean Khanate of the15th–18th centuries, published in Kazan in 2021, and resulted from the 2-year international research project aiming to produce the first academic History of the Crimean Tatars in a five volumes. This is a pioneering and valuable research covering the whole period of the Khanate history, from its formation in the first half of the 15th century to its annexation to the Russian Empire under the reign of Catherine the Great, who abolished the Khanate in 1783. The book discusses different aspects of the Khanate’s everyday life: its conquests and frequent raids against non-Muslim neighbors, foreign and domestic politics, Crimean Tatars’ economy, slave trade, spiritual and material culture, religion, military affairs, demography, their relationship with ethnic and confessional minorities of the Khanate and their Diaspora abroad, images of the Crimean Tatars as the Other constructed and later Orientalized by foreign travelers and observers from Western Europe, Ukraine and Russia. In fact, this book rehabilitates the Crimean Khanate, showing that it was not just a robber’s nest, living off raids on neighbors and the international slave trade, as the late Soviet literature argued. The study fills in a significant gap in contemporary historiography on the subject in the field of Oriental, Russian, Polish, and Ukrainian studies. It also contributes to comparative history of the northern Black sea area at the turn of the early modern times. It is noteworthy that the new series on History of the Crimean Tatars does not dismiss the legacy of the anti-Crimean Soviet literature categorically, but attempts to rethink it all creatively, starting with the pre-revolutionary classic study written by V.D. Smirnov. It resumes revisionist historiography of the Crimean Khanate from Perestroika to the present day proposing possible alternative readings of its history.
Keywords: revisionist historians, Crimean Khanate, Russia, Crimean Tatars, Islam, Oriental studies
For citation: Bobrovnikov V.O. Rehabilitation of the Crimean Khanate by Historians in a five-volumes book about the Crimean Tatars. Krymskoe istoricheskoe obozrenie = Crimean Historical Review. 2023, vol. 10, no. 1, pp. 220–232. DOI: 10.22378/kio.2023.1.220-232 (In Russian)
1. Akchokrakly Osman Nuri, Izbrannye sochineniya po istorii, arkheologii, etnografii [Selected works on history, archeology, and ethnography]. / Sost.: A.A. Nepomnyashchiy, G.N. Kondratyuk, E.Kh. Seydakhmetov, komment. E.I. Seydaliev i dr.. Simferopol: OOO FORMA, 2016. 216 p.: ill. (In Russian)
2. Bodaninsky, Usein, Sobranie sochineniy [Collected Works]. Kazan; Simferopol: Marjani Institute of History of the Tatarstan Academy of Sciences, 2018–2020. Vol. I–III. 272 p.; 264 p.; 544 p. (In Russian)
3. Val’kov D.V. Genuezskaya epigrafika Kryma [Genoese epigraphics in the Crimea]. Moscow: Universitet Dmitriya Pozharskogo, 2015. 368 p., ill. (In Russian)
4. Vozgrin V.E. Istoriya krymskikh tatar: Ocherki po etnicheskoy istoprii korennogo naroda Kryma [History of the Crimean Tatars: Essays on Ethnic History of the Native people of the Crimea]. Vol. I–IV. 4th ed. Simferopol: OOO “Kara deniz production”, 2015. 870 p., ill.; 988 p., ill.; 879 p., ill.; 619 p., ill. (In Russian)
5. Gasprinskiy I. Polnoe sobranie sochineniy [Complete works]. Vol. I–III. / Ed. in chief R.S. Khakimov; ed. S.A. Seitmametova. Kazan; Simferopol: Marjani Institute of History of the Tatarstan Academy of Sciences, 2019, 2017, 2019. 384 p.; 384 p., 24 p., ill.; 560 p., 16 p. ill. (In Russian)
6. Istoriya krymskikh tatar [History of the Crimean Tatars]. Vol. III. Krymskoe khanstvo (XV–XVIII vv.) [The Crimean Khanate (in the 15th – 18th centuries)] / Ed. by I.V. Zaytsev. Kazan: Marjani Institute of History of the Tatarstan Academy of Sciences, 2021. 1024 p., 64 p. ill. (In Russian)
7. Kas’yanov G. “Natsionalizatsiya” istorii na Ukraine [“Nativization of history in Ukraine]. In: Istoricheskaya politika v 21 veke [Historical Politics in the 21st century] / Ed. by A. Miller, M. Lipman. Moscow: NLO, 2002, pp. 217–255. (In Russian)
8. Kayumov R. V Kazani predstavili pervoe akademicheskoe izdanie po istorii krimskikh tatar [The first academic volume on the History of the Crimean Tatars was presented in Kazan [Electronic resourse]. URL: https://www.tatar-inform.ru/news/v-kazani-predstavili-pervoe-akademiceskoe-izdanie-po-istorii-krymskix-tatar-5854284 (In Russian)
9. Mikhaylov V.V. Recenziya na III tom pyatitomnogo izdaniya Istorii krymskikh tatar [review on the 3rd volume of the History of the Crimean Tatars in 5 volumes. The Crimean Khanate (in the 15th – 18th centuries)]. Klio. 2022. No. 10 (190), pp. 154–161. (In Russian)
10. Nadinskiy P.N. Ocherki po istorii Kryma [Essays on the History of the Crimea]. Pt. 1–4. Simferopol: Krymizdat, 1951–1967. 229 p., ill.; 302 p., ill.; 221 p., ill.; 318 p., ill. (In Russian)
11. Petrukhintsev N.N., Vishnyakov Ya.V. Put’ k Tavride: Bor’ba Rossii za vykhod k Chernomu moryu i prisoedinenie Kryma k Rossii [On the way to Tavrida: Russia’s struggle for access to the Black sea and annexation of the Crimea to Russia 1786–1783]. In: Istoriya Kryma / Rossiyskoe voenno-istoricheskoe obshchestvo; E.E. Boytsova et al. Moscow: OLMA Media Grupp, 2015, pp. 113–165. (In Russian)
12. Yakobson A.L. Krym v srednie veka [The Crimea in the middle ages]. Moscow: Nauka, 1973. 174 p. (In Russian)
13. Brockelmann C. Geschichte der arabischen Litteratur [History of the Arabic literature] / Introd. by J.J. Witkam. Vol. I–II. Supplement vol. I–III. Leiden – Boston: E.J. Brill, 2012. (In German)
14. Kirmse S.B. The lawful empire. Legal change and cultural diversity in late tsarist Russia. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2019. 341 p.
15. Burbank J., Cooper F. Empires in world history: power and the politics of difference. Princeton: Princeton University Press, 2010. 511 p.
16. Kumar K. Visions of empire: how five imperial regimes shaped the world. Princeton: Princeton University Press, 2017. 600 p.
About the author: Vladimir O. Bobrovnikov – Cand. Sci. (History), Leading Research Fellow, Chair of the Center for Studies of Central Asia, Caucasus and the Volga-Ural region, Institute of Oriental Studies of the Russian Academy of Sciences (107031, Rozhdestvenka Str., 12, Moscow, Russian Federation); Research Fellow of the Research Laboratory for Analysis and Modeling of Social Processes, Saint Petersburg State University (199034, University embankment, 11, Saint Petersburg, Russian Federation); Professor of the Institute for Oriental and Classical Studies, National Research University – Higher School of Economics (105066, Staraya Basmannaya Str., 21/4, Moscow, Russian Federation); firstname.lastname@example.org